"Senior Vice President and General Counsel, Intel Corporation
Federal Trade Commission and Department of Justice
Hearings on Section 2 of the Sherman Act
February 13, 2007
I want to begin by thanking the antitrust enforcement agencies for giving me the opportunity to participate in these very important hearings. I appreciate the considerable effort that has been devoted to these hearings and the dedication that the agencies’ able staffs have brought to bear on these issues. I am confident that the agencies’ report will make a significant contribution to the analysis of single-firm conduct.
The development of the law of single-firm conduct is of obvious interest to my company.
We are the defendant in a highly visible Section 2 litigation that has generated considerable interest in the press and among antitrust specialists. I was somewhat dismayed to see that the plaintiff in our case used these hearings as a forum to rebroadcast allegations that it has already made in its district court filings and in the press.
With respect to this, I will only say the following:
Intel prefers to litigate in the courtroom, and I therefore will not use this policy forum to argue the merits of our case, other than to state that I unequivocally deny the allegations that were made against Intel at the January 30 hearing in Berkeley.
Instead, my remarks today will address the policy issues that have been the focus of these hearings.
In particular, I would like to discuss the appropriate role of Section 2 with respect to pricing and discounting practices. I hope that my company’s perspective on these policy issues will help to advance the debate that the agencies have generated through these hearings.
At the risk of stating the obvious, the challenge of Section 2 enforcement is to curb anticompetitive single-firm conduct that harms consumers without deterring the type of aggressive competition that benefits consumers through lower prices and greater innovation.
This is a great challenge. As Professors William Baumol and Janusz Ordover observed 20 years ago; “[t]here is a specter that haunts our antitrust institutions.
Its threat is that, far from serving as the bulwark of competition, these institutions will become the most powerful instrument in the hands of those who wish to subvert it.”
1 Professor Baumol and Ordover stressed the important concept that “rules that make vigorous competition dangerous clearly foster protectionism,”
2 and they warned of the “runner-up who hopes to impose legal obstacles on the vigorous competitive efforts of his all-too-successful rival.”3 These observations were more recently echoed by Professors Preston McAfee and Nicholas Vakkur, who catalogued seven strategic abuses of the antitrust laws, including punishing non-cooperative behavior and preventing a successful firm from competing aggressively.4 In his presentation at these hearings, Professor McAfee stressed that the antitrust laws can be used to “harass,” “harm,” and “extort” in order “to induce cooperation.”
5 The strategic abuse of the antitrust laws is of more than a passing concern to Intel. I was therefore particularly pleased to see both Chairman Majoras and Assistant Attorney General Barnett, in their remarks at the beginning of these hearings, underscore the importance of having rules of law that do not deter procompetitive, aggressive competition. As Chairman Majoras stated in her remarks, “there is consensus that antitrust standards that govern unilateral conduct must not deter competition, efficiency, or innovation. This is why we frequently worry about ‘false positives.’
Pervasive and aggressive competition, in which firms consistently try to better each other by providing higher quality goods and services at lower costs, is crucial to maximizing consumer welfare and economic growth.”
6 Assistant Attorney General Barnett echoed one of our chief concerns, as a business that
devotes considerable resources to antitrust compliance, by stating that antitrust rules in the unilateral conduct area must set forth “clear, objective standards that businesses can follow and are also administrable for enforcers, courts, and juries.”
7 Particularly in the area of pricing behavior, as the Supreme Court has emphasized on many occasions and Mr. Barnett endorsed in his remarks, antitrust rules must “avoid ‘chilling legitimate price cutting.’”
8 This requires objective standards that rely on information that is available to corporate decisionmakers when they act and that allow more efficient firms to exploit their cost advantages. Sound antitrust policy also requires sensitivity to the potential misuse of the antitrust laws by less efficient competitors to reduce price competition.
Government enforcement policy has been appropriately cautious in the area of pricing,
taking heed of the risk of chilling the very conduct that the antitrust laws seek to encourage – that is aggressive price cutting – and thereby harming consumers. At the same time, the enforcement agencies have aggressively pursued many other forms of conduct that anticompetitively creates or maintains monopoly power.
Without getting into the merits of any individual case, it is 4 R. Preston McAfee & Nicholas V. Vakkur, The Strategic Abuse of the Antitrust Laws, 2 J. Strategic Mgmt. 1, 2-3 (2004), available at http://www.hss.caltech.edu/~mcafee/Papers/PDF/strategicantitrust.pdf.
5 R. Preston McAfee, The Strategic Abuse of the Antitrust Law, at 9 (Dec. 6, 2006), available at
http://www.usdoj.gov/atr/public/hearings/single_firm/docs/220041.pdf.
6 Remarks of Deborah Platt Majoras, Chairman, Federal Trade Commission, The Consumer
Reigns: Using Section 2 to Ensure a “Competitive Kingdom” at 9 (June 20, 2006), available at
http://www.usdoj.gov/atr/public/hearings/single_firm/docs/219108.pdf .
7 Remarks of Thomas O. Barnett, Assistant Attorney General for Antitrust, The Gales of
Creative Destruction:
The Need for Clear and Objective Standards for Enforcing Section 2 of the
Sherman Act at 17 (June 20, 2006), available at
http://www.ftc.gov/os/sectiontwohearings/docs/Barnett-statement.pdf .
8 Id. at 9 (quoting Brooke Group Ltd. v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 509 U.S. 209 ,
223 (1993).
important to note that the agencies have pursued a number of different forms of conduct under
Section 2 theories. Recent cases include:
• Patent settlements that may delay entry and thereby extend incumbent suppliers’
exclusive rights to supply products.
• Representations to standard-setting organizations or governmental bodies regarding
patent positions.
• Exclusive dealing.
• Product design.
The enforcement agencies have recognized the challenges inherent in aggressive
enforcement of Section 2 cases.
While bringing a number of Section 2 cases in recent years, the agencies have also expressed cognizance of the potential misuse of the antitrust laws by less efficient rivals.
As Deputy Assistant Attorney General Masoudi has noted elsewhere, ”[a]n antitrust agency must be cautious about complaints it receives from competitors.
Such complainants often try to avoid legitimate competition by seeking protection from the government from competitive pressures.”9 This is particularly true when the subject of such complaints is price cutting.
We hope that the agencies’ final report on these hearings will impart to the courts
the benefits of the agencies’ experience in enforcing the law aggressively while resisting the
demands of complainants who seek to use Section 2 to dampen competition.
I read with considerable interest the assertion made at the January 30th hearings that the
enforcement agencies have been asleep on the job, that they have somehow failed to enforce section 2.
This view cannot be squared with the record of aggressive enforcement that I just
outlined.
It was also suggested at that hearing that the enforcement agencies have given the hightech
area a free pass. Even ignoring the fact that high technology is not limited to the computer
industry, this claim is equally hard to square with reality. The agencies’ recent actions in the
high tech area include:
• Monopolization cases against Microsoft and Rambus.
• A substantial number of merger enforcement cases involving software companies
(Oracle / PeopleSoft being the best known, but it is only one of many) and many
other high tech markets, including communications technology, disaster recovery
systems, and 3D prototyping.
• Massive fines imposed on DRAM companies (and jail sentences on company executives) and ongoing criminal investigations involving SRAM, flat panel displays, and
graphics processors.
The criminal cases and investigations are particularly notable because they involve price
fixing – conduct designed to and having the effect of making consumers pay more. It seems
eminently sensible that antitrust enforcement should direct itself at conduct that demonstrably
leads to higher prices rather than to attack price cutting, which is the very conduct that the
competition laws are designed to promote.
It was suggested at the Berkeley hearing that antitrust enforcement should be directed at price cutting and that the “reality” (as opposed to the “myth”), is that consumers are harmed when prices come down due to discounting. Here, I could not disagree more with the position espoused by AMD.
On the issue of discounting, we have a
fundamentally different point of view. We think that enforcement resources are appropriately
directed at conduct that makes consumers pay more, not conduct that gives them lower prices.
I believe that our position is supported by both the law as articulated by the Supreme
Court and by very sound policy considerations that underlie the Court’s decisions. The Court’s
statement in Matsushita cogently expresses both the policy and its underpinnings: “[C]utting
prices in order to increase business often is the very essence of competition. Thus, mistaken inferences in cases such as this one are especially costly, because they chill the very conduct the
antitrust laws are designed to protect.”10 Justice Breyer, while sitting on the First Circuit, made a similar observation in the Barry Wright case:
“[T]he consequence of a mistake here is not simply to force a firm to forego legitimate business activity it wishes to pursue; rather, it is to
penalize a procompetitive price cut, perhaps the most desirable activity (from an antitrust perspective) that can take place in a concentrated industry where prices typically exceed costs.”11 This policy has broad application across all areas of pricing conduct.
As the Supreme Court said in ARCO v. USA Petroleum, “Low prices benefit consumers regardless of how those prices are set, and so long as they are above predatory levels, they do not threaten competition....
We have adhered to this principle regardless of the type of antitrust claim involved.”12 This is
not only the law, but it is also the right antitrust policy.
This policy recognizes that false positives, which are very likely to occur in the absence of clear-cut cost-based rules, can impose a high cost on society by punishing, and thereby, deterring aggressive price competition.
The courts and the enforcement agencies have recognized that the very tangible bird in the hand, lower prices enjoyed by consumers today, must not be sacrificed for the bird in the bush, the speculative (and almost always illogical) hope that attacking price cutting and thereby producing higher prices today will produce lower prices tomorrow.
I can tell you from personal experience, from years of advising a very successful corporation
on how to compete against a very aggressive rival, that the need for clarity in this area is
paramount. The challenge in counseling a business is to ensure that the company adheres to its
Matsushita Elec. Indus. Co. v. Zenith Radio Corp., 475 U.S. 574, 594 (1986)
11 Barry Wright Corp. v. ITT Grinnell Corp., 724 F.2d 227, 235 (1st Cir. 1983)
12 Atlantic Richfield Co. v. USA Petroleum Co., 495 U.S. 328, 340 (1990).
5 legal obligations without forcing it to engage in “gentlemanly competition” in which business
opportunities are squandered by pricing higher than needed to win the deal, even though the deal can be won profitably.
Intel has long had a cost advantage due to its strong leadership position in manufacturing, and it is important to me and to the other lawyers advising our management that we neither deprive the company of the competitive advantages that come from its hard-won lower cost position nor deprive consumers of the benefit of lower prices, simply because of unclear antitrust rules.
You may have recently read on the front page of the New York Times about Intel’s latest
breakthrough in semiconductor manufacturing technology. This is the most significant change in
the materials used to manufacture silicon chips since Intel pioneered the modern integratedcircuit transistor more than four decades ago. It is no accident that Intel was first to achieve this breakthrough.
Our company has enjoyed unparalleled leadership in manufacturing for most of
its existence.
And the benefits of this leadership position are very tangible. With every new
generation of manufacturing technology, each of which is introduced roughly every two years,
we double the number of chips that can be produced on a wafer, holding both the wafer size and
the chip design constant.
This means that the manufacturing cost of any given chip is cut by
50% when the new manufacturing technology is introduced.
The story is a bit more complicated
because we always take advantage of the lower cost to pack more features into new chips, which
trades off some of the cost savings for better performing products; but the cost advantage of
being first to adopt the new manufacturing technology is large and very tangible. Our recent
manufacturing technology breakthrough will ensure that we can continue to progress along the
same path for many years to come.
Intel has been on average nine months to a year ahead of its competitors in adopting new manufacturing technologies.
This means that in any given two-year cycle, we are alone in achieving the cost savings during the first year and are ramped up on the new manufacturing process during the second year when the competition is just beginning to introduce the new manufacturing technology.
Our sales executives want to use the cost advantage that they enjoy as a result of our manufacturing leadership to win business. Clear antitrust rules are essential to my ability to guide them to a winning outcome that does nothing more than exploit our competitive
advantage.
A clear and sensible rule is offered by the Areeda & Hovenkamp treatise in its latest supplement:
“[W]hen a discount is offered on a single product (whether a quantity or market share
discount), the discount should be lawful if the price after all discounts are taken into account
exceeds the defendant’s marginal cost or average variable cost.
That is, such discounts are
covered by antitrust’s ordinary predatory pricing rule.”
13 A similar approach has been proposed by former FTC Chairman Tim Muris, who advocates a “modified Brooke Group test” based on
whether the price of the total amount of goods sold exceeds the cost of the goods.14
13 Philip Areeda and Herbert Hovenkamp, Antitrust Law ¶ 749 at 326 (Supp. 2006).
14 Timothy J. Muris, Comments on Antitrust Law, Economics, and Bundled Discounts, submitted to the Antitrust Modernization Commission at 21-27 (July 15, 2005), available at
Cost-based rules have a number of advantages, beginning with the avoidance of false
positives.
They enable companies to base pricing decisions on what they know, their own cost
structures and the relationship of price to cost, instead of speculation about the meaning of
potentially vague jury instructions that say, for example, that a firm must be allowed to compete aggressively but that it cannot behave in an unnecessarily restrictive manner.
Because costbased rules are more predictable than the vague standards that have been applied by some courts in Section 2 cases, they are also inherently more administrable. And they appropriately condemn the type of discounting that does cause competitive harm – predatory pricing.
The antitrust laws are a powerful instrument for consumer protection, but they can also be misused by rivals to attack competition.
It is essential that the antitrust rules in the pricing area protect consumers both from anticompetitive conduct that create, maintain, or enhance a monopoly and from anticompetitive abuses of the law by rivals that seek to stifle price competition.
Thank you once again for the opportunity to provide these comments.
Source of this Post
http://www.intel.com/pressroom/legal/docs/070213sewelltestimony.pdf
CEO Paul Otellini
D. Bruce Sewell - Bruce Sewell - Durward Bruce Sewell
Showing posts with label Evil Intel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Evil Intel. Show all posts
Wednesday, January 6, 2010
Friday, January 1, 2010
FEDERAL COMPLAINT SERVICE - Intel Corporation - Bruce Sewell
"From: Eliot I. Bernstein
Sent: Friday, February 27, 2009 11:23 PM
To: D. Bruce Sewell, Senior Vice President -
General Counsel @ Intel Corporation
Cc: Caroline Prochotska Rogers, Esquire
(caroline@cprogers.com); Marc R. Garber Esq. @ Flaster
Greenberg P.C.; Michele M. Mulrooney Esq. -
Jackoway Tyerman Wertheimer Austen
Mandelbaum & Morris (MMulrooney@JTWAMM.com)
Subject: FEDERAL COMPLAINT SERVICE Docket No. 08-4873-cv FINAL SIGNED BRIEF
PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT BERNSTEIN USCA 2nd Circ 13988ll.pdf - Adobe Acrobat Professional D. Bruce Sewell and Lawrence S. Palley,
Please accept the following as service of my Brief in the USCA 2nd Circ. as INTEL
CORPORATION and Lawrence S. Palley, Director of Business Development are named
Defendants in these matters. Please report this liability to all proper regulatory agencies,
shareholders, and liability carriers.
Thank you, Eliot Bernstein
From: Eliot I. BernsteinSent: Friday, February 27, 2009 7:05 PM
To: Deborah Holmes, Deputy Clerk,
United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit; Pro Se
Cases @ United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit;
Civil Cases @ United States Court
of Appeals for the Second Circuit
Cc: Caroline Prochotska Rogers, Esquire;
Marc R. Garber Esq. @ Flaster Greenberg P.C.;
Michele M. Mulrooney Esq. -
Jackoway Tyerman Wertheimer Austen Mandelbaum & Morris; 'Andy Dietz';
Subject: Docket No. 08-4873-cv FINAL SIGNED BRIEF PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT BERNSTEIN USCA 2nd Circ 13988ll.pdf - Adobe Acrobat Professional
I-VIEW-IT TECHNOLOGIES, INC.
Surf with Vision
Dear Deborah,
I have enclosed, per our conversations and your instructions, a PDF copy of my FINAL
SIGNED BRIEF FOR PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT BERNSTEIN USCA 2nd Circ for
Docket No. 08-4873-cv.
I have also sent the document via US Mail as you specified and thus this electronic communication and the mailed copy should constitute a timely filing.
I have attached in the document the following, 1. US Postmaster Certified Letter Receipts showing the same Document as attached herein has been mailed and postmarked with the date Friday, February 27th 2009, 2. A signed Electronic Notification Agreement, 3. A Signed Anti-Virus Certification Form of which a virus check was performed, 4. A Signed Notice of Appearance Form and 5. A Signed Brief.
If you need additional information, please feel free to contact me.
Eliot I. Bernstein
Inventor
Iviewit Technologies, Inc.
www.iviewit.tv
From: Eliot I. Bernstein
Sent: Friday, March 13, 2009 7:13 PM
To: D. Bruce Sewell, Senior Vice President
- General Counsel @ Intel
Corporation(bruce.sewell@intel.com);
Paul S. Otellini, President and Chief Executive Officer @
Intel Corporation (paul.otellini@intel.com);
Steven R. Rodgers, Vice President and Associate
General Counsel Legal and Corporate Affairs, Director,
Litigation @ Intel Corporation
(steven.rodgers@intel.com)
Cc: Caroline Prochotska Rogers, Esquire
(caroline@cprogers.com); Michele M. Mulrooney Esq. -
Jackoway Tyerman Wertheimer Austen Mandelbaum & Morris (MMulrooney@JTWAMM.com);
Marc R. Garber Esq. @ Flaster Greenberg P.C.; Marc R. Garber Esq. @ Flaster Greenberg P.C.
(marcrgarber@verizon.net); 'Andy Dietz'; 'Barry Becker'; 'krhall007@aol.com'
Subject: INTEL DEFENDANT IN FEDERAL LAWSUIT
Please see the attached Amended Complaint wherein Intel is a Named Defendant in a Trillion Dollar Lawsuit.
Please report this liability to all proper regulatory agencies,
shareholders and liability carriers.
Thank you,
Eliot Bernstein "
Source of This Post
http://iviewit.tv/press/press4.pdf
Sent: Friday, February 27, 2009 11:23 PM
To: D. Bruce Sewell, Senior Vice President -
General Counsel @ Intel Corporation
Cc: Caroline Prochotska Rogers, Esquire
(caroline@cprogers.com); Marc R. Garber Esq. @ Flaster
Greenberg P.C.; Michele M. Mulrooney Esq. -
Jackoway Tyerman Wertheimer Austen
Mandelbaum & Morris (MMulrooney@JTWAMM.com)
Subject: FEDERAL COMPLAINT SERVICE Docket No. 08-4873-cv FINAL SIGNED BRIEF
PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT BERNSTEIN USCA 2nd Circ 13988ll.pdf - Adobe Acrobat Professional D. Bruce Sewell and Lawrence S. Palley,
Please accept the following as service of my Brief in the USCA 2nd Circ. as INTEL
CORPORATION and Lawrence S. Palley, Director of Business Development are named
Defendants in these matters. Please report this liability to all proper regulatory agencies,
shareholders, and liability carriers.
Thank you, Eliot Bernstein
From: Eliot I. BernsteinSent: Friday, February 27, 2009 7:05 PM
To: Deborah Holmes, Deputy Clerk,
United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit; Pro Se
Cases @ United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit;
Civil Cases @ United States Court
of Appeals for the Second Circuit
Cc: Caroline Prochotska Rogers, Esquire;
Marc R. Garber Esq. @ Flaster Greenberg P.C.;
Michele M. Mulrooney Esq. -
Jackoway Tyerman Wertheimer Austen Mandelbaum & Morris; 'Andy Dietz';
Subject: Docket No. 08-4873-cv FINAL SIGNED BRIEF PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT BERNSTEIN USCA 2nd Circ 13988ll.pdf - Adobe Acrobat Professional
I-VIEW-IT TECHNOLOGIES, INC.
Surf with Vision
Dear Deborah,
I have enclosed, per our conversations and your instructions, a PDF copy of my FINAL
SIGNED BRIEF FOR PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT BERNSTEIN USCA 2nd Circ for
Docket No. 08-4873-cv.
I have also sent the document via US Mail as you specified and thus this electronic communication and the mailed copy should constitute a timely filing.
I have attached in the document the following, 1. US Postmaster Certified Letter Receipts showing the same Document as attached herein has been mailed and postmarked with the date Friday, February 27th 2009, 2. A signed Electronic Notification Agreement, 3. A Signed Anti-Virus Certification Form of which a virus check was performed, 4. A Signed Notice of Appearance Form and 5. A Signed Brief.
If you need additional information, please feel free to contact me.
Eliot I. Bernstein
Inventor
Iviewit Technologies, Inc.
www.iviewit.tv
From: Eliot I. Bernstein
Sent: Friday, March 13, 2009 7:13 PM
To: D. Bruce Sewell, Senior Vice President
- General Counsel @ Intel
Corporation(bruce.sewell@intel.com);
Paul S. Otellini, President and Chief Executive Officer @
Intel Corporation (paul.otellini@intel.com);
Steven R. Rodgers, Vice President and Associate
General Counsel Legal and Corporate Affairs, Director,
Litigation @ Intel Corporation
(steven.rodgers@intel.com)
Cc: Caroline Prochotska Rogers, Esquire
(caroline@cprogers.com); Michele M. Mulrooney Esq. -
Jackoway Tyerman Wertheimer Austen Mandelbaum & Morris (MMulrooney@JTWAMM.com);
Marc R. Garber Esq. @ Flaster Greenberg P.C.; Marc R. Garber Esq. @ Flaster Greenberg P.C.
(marcrgarber@verizon.net); 'Andy Dietz'; 'Barry Becker'; 'krhall007@aol.com'
Subject: INTEL DEFENDANT IN FEDERAL LAWSUIT
Please see the attached Amended Complaint wherein Intel is a Named Defendant in a Trillion Dollar Lawsuit.
Please report this liability to all proper regulatory agencies,
shareholders and liability carriers.
Thank you,
Eliot Bernstein "
Source of This Post
http://iviewit.tv/press/press4.pdf
To: Sewell, Bruce - D. Bruce Sewell Intel Corporation - Intel ABOVE the Law, not MADE to Honor Contracts, WHY?
"From: P. Stephen Lamont
Sent: Tuesday, March 06, 2007 8:14 PM
To: Sewell, Bruce - Bruce Sewell
Cc: Eliot I. Bernstein; Caroline P. Rogers Esq.; Andrew Dietz; Simon, David; Rodgers, Steve R
Subject: RE: Email to Paul S. Otellini
Mr. Bruce Sewell:
Thank you for your quick response on behalf of Intel, and, of course, Iviewit will abide by your wishes and communicate directly with you in the immediate future. Iviewit has the reputation in the community for creating those solutions necessary for the benefit of our children and our children's children.
Moreover, and perhaps this was not made clear in my previous email, but Iviewit's irritation stems more from the fact that contracts were walked away from in 1999, whereby Iviewit presented to Real 3D, taught them how to scale video and zoom on images without pixelation and for delivery over low bandwidth networks (clearly, we later found that such solutions apply to all networks at any higher bandwidth), witnessed Real 3D's validation of same, executed NDA's and alliance contracts with Real 3D, saw the acquisition by Intel with the promise that they would abide by such confidentialities and contracts, then saw the then Intel employees halt any further communication.
Second to this issue would be my recent discussion with SSG and DHG concerning Viiv, where you may know better than I what future business emphasis may be steered for this platform.
Additionally, grant it, I was not a participant, as I only assumed my post in December 2001, but at this point may I suggest a reverse chronological approach that might bring us to the heart of the matters in a quicker fashion:
• I have attached my email of December 12 to Rajeev Kapur (SSG) and David Vogel (DHG);
• Attached v-cards for those SSG and DHG employees concerned;
• Mutual production of executed Iviewit and Real 3D contracts that Intel assumed;
• Mutual production of Iviewit and Real 3D NDA's that Intel assumed; and
• As Intel is intimately familiar with its just past Managing Director in the Intel Capital Group, Hassan Miah, a discussion with Mr. Miah, as to what Iviewit is and what Iviewit does (v-card attached for your convenience), and a discussion with former head of Real 3D, Gerald Stanley, is in order (contact information unknown to Iviewit).
Iviewit looks forward to your response to this proposed approach and working together with Intel on these matters, and hopefully my friends in SSG and DHG; as should be clear from the email history attached, it is not Iviewit's style nor interest in a quick payment, but keeping our eye on the real prize, 105 million U.S. digital households, together.
Dear Mr. Lamont,
Given the nature of the allegations contained in your e-mail to Mr. Paul Otellini dated March 6, 2007, I have been asked to respond to you on behalf of Intel Corporation.
Intel treats the use of third party intellectual property very seriously.
the number, date of issuance, and ownership for each patent or patents that you believe Intel has infringed; each claim, including the claim number and a brief description of the specific claim language, that you believe Intel has infringed;
each Intel product that you allege infringes the patents and claims identified in answers #1 and #2; a brief description of the structures or methods within each product identified in answer #3 that you allege to be infringing;
a brief statement regarding the basis for your belief that the Intel products are infringing, i.e.,
describe the documentation or testing that you rely upon as the foundation for your allegations;
and, the names of the individuals within DHG and SSG with whom you have already communicated regarding the technology or the intellectual property rights that are the subject of your allegations, including a copy of the "December 12, 2006 email to DHG and SSG" referenced in your most recent note.
Receipt of this preliminary information will enable Intel to investigate and analyze your claims.
Your failure to provide any of the information requested will delay the point at which we can
effectively begin our investigation.
For the immediate future please communicate directly with me rather than with Mr. Otellini or any other executives within the company. As this matter progresses I may ask you to work with other lawyers either inside Intel or retained on behalf of Intel.
Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.
Sincerely,
Bruce Sewell
Senior Vice President
General Counsel
Intel Corporation
By way of introduction, I am CEO of Iviewit Holdings, Inc., and its subsidiaries, affiliates, and
related parties, where we have designed and developed video frame manipulation techniques
and image overlay systems for the encoding, delivery of, and rendering/decoding of, when
combined with other proprietary technologies, DVD quality video across all transmission networks and viewable on all display devices with the value propositions of lower bandwidth, processing, and storage requirements than other solutions than do not utilize Iviewit techniques and systems;
Hassan Miah was an early on looker and termed Iviewit solutions "Holy Grail" technologies, and a tagline we have used more than once.
Since October 2006, we have been in touch with Intel's Digital Home Group through the SSG
people when it became clear that the Intel G695 Express Chipset, and any other chipset
designed for the Viiv platform, probably through the chipset functions of, including but not limited to, Clear Video processing, overlaps our patent pending claims filed in 2000 in rendering full screen, full frame rate video encoded by your major motion picture studio partners who, upon information and belief, have all adopted Iviewit's patent ending video scaling and image overlay techniques.
Moreover, the issue is more serious than outlined above, and as we have discussed that it is mathematically impossible to deliver DVD quality, full screen, full frame rate video, in less than ideal bandwidth, storage, and processing power conditions without overlapping Iviewit's
proprietary rights, and since Iviewit management began discussions with representatives of Real 3D, Inc. some years ago we have watched our techniques drive across your product groups, including but not limited to microprocessors and chipsets for home entertainment PCs, and embedded consumer electronics designs such as digital televisions, video recorders, and set-top boxes.
Of course, it is Iviewit's goal to resolve the situation of the unauthorized use of Iviewit techniques embodied in prior Iviewit/Real 3D contracts and agreements in the easiest and most seamless way possible, prior to my shareholders pushing me to an edge I would rather not walk upon at this time, but will do so if the need be.
Please let us know when you are available for a conversation with our Founder, Eliot Bernstein,
and myself at your earliest convenience.
To: Caroline P. Rogers Esq.; Andrew Dietz
Cc: Eliot I. Bernstein
Subject: Intel Email and Advanced Royalty Agreement
Moreover, the issue is more serious than outlined above, and as we have discussed it is
mathematically impossible to deliver DVD quality, full screen, full frame rate video, in less than
ideal bandwidth, storage, and processing power conditions without overlapping Iviewit's
proprietary rights, and since Iviewit management began discussions with representatives of Real 3D, Inc. some years ago we have watched our techniques drive across your product groups, including but not limited to microprocessors and chipsets for home entertainment PCs, and
embedded consumer electronics designs such as digital televisions, video recorders, and set-top
boxes.
Please take notice that this is advise of a future complaint seeking permanent injunction, and that the previous offer of license is withdrawn, and is substituted in its entirety by the attached
agreement, executable only for 30 days post hence, else Intel must CEASE AND DESIST the use of rendering full screen, full frame rate video and image overlays where an image can be zoomed upon and panned without pixelation from Intel products, and please advise if anything will prevent you from accepting our demand, in which case we will file suit shortly thereafter complaining of breach of prior confidential disclosures and our attached offer will be deemed withdrawn;
certainly, as a public company governed by the Securities and Exchange Act of 1934, you have
perfect record keeping of those 1999 discussions and the agreements signed thereunder.
Finally, I await timely execution of the attached and your request of wire transfer instructions,
where Iviewit is firmly committed to protecting its proprietary rights against any and all knowing and willful breaches of its confidential disclosures and disregard of recent advise and discussions.
Source of Post
http://iviewit.tv/press/press4.pdf
Sent: Tuesday, March 06, 2007 8:14 PM
To: Sewell, Bruce - Bruce Sewell
Cc: Eliot I. Bernstein; Caroline P. Rogers Esq.; Andrew Dietz; Simon, David; Rodgers, Steve R
Subject: RE: Email to Paul S. Otellini
Mr. Bruce Sewell:
Thank you for your quick response on behalf of Intel, and, of course, Iviewit will abide by your wishes and communicate directly with you in the immediate future. Iviewit has the reputation in the community for creating those solutions necessary for the benefit of our children and our children's children.
Moreover, and perhaps this was not made clear in my previous email, but Iviewit's irritation stems more from the fact that contracts were walked away from in 1999, whereby Iviewit presented to Real 3D, taught them how to scale video and zoom on images without pixelation and for delivery over low bandwidth networks (clearly, we later found that such solutions apply to all networks at any higher bandwidth), witnessed Real 3D's validation of same, executed NDA's and alliance contracts with Real 3D, saw the acquisition by Intel with the promise that they would abide by such confidentialities and contracts, then saw the then Intel employees halt any further communication.
Second to this issue would be my recent discussion with SSG and DHG concerning Viiv, where you may know better than I what future business emphasis may be steered for this platform.
Additionally, grant it, I was not a participant, as I only assumed my post in December 2001, but at this point may I suggest a reverse chronological approach that might bring us to the heart of the matters in a quicker fashion:
• I have attached my email of December 12 to Rajeev Kapur (SSG) and David Vogel (DHG);
• Attached v-cards for those SSG and DHG employees concerned;
• Mutual production of executed Iviewit and Real 3D contracts that Intel assumed;
• Mutual production of Iviewit and Real 3D NDA's that Intel assumed; and
• As Intel is intimately familiar with its just past Managing Director in the Intel Capital Group, Hassan Miah, a discussion with Mr. Miah, as to what Iviewit is and what Iviewit does (v-card attached for your convenience), and a discussion with former head of Real 3D, Gerald Stanley, is in order (contact information unknown to Iviewit).
Iviewit looks forward to your response to this proposed approach and working together with Intel on these matters, and hopefully my friends in SSG and DHG; as should be clear from the email history attached, it is not Iviewit's style nor interest in a quick payment, but keeping our eye on the real prize, 105 million U.S. digital households, together.
******
From: Sewell, Bruce [mailto:bruce.sewell@intel.com]
Sent: Tuesday, March 06, 2007 6:28 PM
Cc: Rodgers, Steve R; Simon, David
Subject: Email to Paul S. Otellini
From: Sewell, Bruce [mailto:bruce.sewell@intel.com]
Sent: Tuesday, March 06, 2007 6:28 PM
Cc: Rodgers, Steve R; Simon, David
Subject: Email to Paul S. Otellini
Dear Mr. Lamont,
Given the nature of the allegations contained in your e-mail to Mr. Paul Otellini dated March 6, 2007, I have been asked to respond to you on behalf of Intel Corporation.
Intel treats the use of third party intellectual property very seriously.
We endeavor to investigate and resolve any legitimate claim of unlicensed use that is brought to our attention. At the same time we are frequently a target for spurious or premature claims by individuals or companies hoping for a quick nuisance payment.
In order to properly characterize and respond to your assertions I must ask you to provide us with some more pertinent information about the nature of the intellectual property you believe you own and the basis for your claim that certain Intel products may infringe those rights. Specifically, please provide the following information at your convenience so that we may properly analyze your claims:
the number, date of issuance, and ownership for each patent or patents that you believe Intel has infringed; each claim, including the claim number and a brief description of the specific claim language, that you believe Intel has infringed;
each Intel product that you allege infringes the patents and claims identified in answers #1 and #2; a brief description of the structures or methods within each product identified in answer #3 that you allege to be infringing;
a brief statement regarding the basis for your belief that the Intel products are infringing, i.e.,
describe the documentation or testing that you rely upon as the foundation for your allegations;
and, the names of the individuals within DHG and SSG with whom you have already communicated regarding the technology or the intellectual property rights that are the subject of your allegations, including a copy of the "December 12, 2006 email to DHG and SSG" referenced in your most recent note.
Receipt of this preliminary information will enable Intel to investigate and analyze your claims.
Your failure to provide any of the information requested will delay the point at which we can
effectively begin our investigation.
For the immediate future please communicate directly with me rather than with Mr. Otellini or any other executives within the company. As this matter progresses I may ask you to work with other lawyers either inside Intel or retained on behalf of Intel.
Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.
Sincerely,
Bruce Sewell
Senior Vice President
General Counsel
Intel Corporation
******
From: P. Stephen Lamont
From: P. Stephen Lamont
Sent: Tuesday, March 06, 2007 11:38 AM
To: Arena, Marise G
Cc: Caroline P. Rogers Esq.; Andrew Dietz; Eliot I. Bernstein
Subject: Email to Paul S. Otellini
Importance: High
Dear Mr. Paul Otellini:
To: Arena, Marise G
Cc: Caroline P. Rogers Esq.; Andrew Dietz; Eliot I. Bernstein
Subject: Email to Paul S. Otellini
Importance: High
Dear Mr. Paul Otellini:
By way of introduction, I am CEO of Iviewit Holdings, Inc., and its subsidiaries, affiliates, and
related parties, where we have designed and developed video frame manipulation techniques
and image overlay systems for the encoding, delivery of, and rendering/decoding of, when
combined with other proprietary technologies, DVD quality video across all transmission networks and viewable on all display devices with the value propositions of lower bandwidth, processing, and storage requirements than other solutions than do not utilize Iviewit techniques and systems;
Hassan Miah was an early on looker and termed Iviewit solutions "Holy Grail" technologies, and a tagline we have used more than once.
Since October 2006, we have been in touch with Intel's Digital Home Group through the SSG
people when it became clear that the Intel G695 Express Chipset, and any other chipset
designed for the Viiv platform, probably through the chipset functions of, including but not limited to, Clear Video processing, overlaps our patent pending claims filed in 2000 in rendering full screen, full frame rate video encoded by your major motion picture studio partners who, upon information and belief, have all adopted Iviewit's patent ending video scaling and image overlay techniques.
Moreover, we have waited patiently for an answer to the implications of my
December 12, 2006 email to DHG and SSG, specifically advising them that Intel, in the rendering of full screen, full frame rate Iviewit encoded video from your studio partners on including but not limited to the Viiv platform, is directly infringing on our proprietary rights. Since their answer has not been forthcoming in almost 90 days, I can only assume that Intel is continuing to render such video in blatant disregard for Iviewit's patent pending claims and in direct, disregard for Iviewit's proprietary rights.
December 12, 2006 email to DHG and SSG, specifically advising them that Intel, in the rendering of full screen, full frame rate Iviewit encoded video from your studio partners on including but not limited to the Viiv platform, is directly infringing on our proprietary rights. Since their answer has not been forthcoming in almost 90 days, I can only assume that Intel is continuing to render such video in blatant disregard for Iviewit's patent pending claims and in direct, disregard for Iviewit's proprietary rights.
Moreover, the issue is more serious than outlined above, and as we have discussed that it is mathematically impossible to deliver DVD quality, full screen, full frame rate video, in less than ideal bandwidth, storage, and processing power conditions without overlapping Iviewit's
proprietary rights, and since Iviewit management began discussions with representatives of Real 3D, Inc. some years ago we have watched our techniques drive across your product groups, including but not limited to microprocessors and chipsets for home entertainment PCs, and embedded consumer electronics designs such as digital televisions, video recorders, and set-top boxes.
Since Intel acquired the Real 3D business in 1999, pursuant to Iviewit/Real 3D contracts and confidentiality agreements, therefore, Intel has consistently conducted these unauthorized uses on the aforementioned products, without limitation, learned in prior business discussions with executed contracts, confidentiality agreements, and such.
Of course, it is Iviewit's goal to resolve the situation of the unauthorized use of Iviewit techniques embodied in prior Iviewit/Real 3D contracts and agreements in the easiest and most seamless way possible, prior to my shareholders pushing me to an edge I would rather not walk upon at this time, but will do so if the need be.
Please let us know when you are available for a conversation with our Founder, Eliot Bernstein,
and myself at your earliest convenience.
******
From: P. Stephen Lamont
From: P. Stephen Lamont
Sent: Friday, March 02, 2007 1:35 PM
To: Caroline P. Rogers Esq.; Andrew Dietz
Cc: Eliot I. Bernstein
Subject: Intel Email and Advanced Royalty Agreement
-- Comments Requested
Importance: High
David/Raj,
We have waited patiently for an answer to the implications of my December 12, 2006 email,
specifically advising you that Intel, in the rendering of full screen, full frame rate Iviewit encoded video from your studio partners on including but not limited to the Viiv platform, is directly
infringing on our proprietary rights.
Importance: High
David/Raj,
We have waited patiently for an answer to the implications of my December 12, 2006 email,
specifically advising you that Intel, in the rendering of full screen, full frame rate Iviewit encoded video from your studio partners on including but not limited to the Viiv platform, is directly
infringing on our proprietary rights.
Since your answer has not been forthcoming in more than 60 days, I can only assume that you are continuing to render such video in blatant disregard for Iviewit's patent pending claims and in direct, disregard for Iviewit's proprietary rights.
Therefore, unfortunately, Iviewit must demand that you CEASE AND DESIST rendering such Iviewit encoded scaled video and imaging according to our claims, else we must follow-up on the issue in due course.
Moreover, the issue is more serious than outlined above, and as we have discussed it is
mathematically impossible to deliver DVD quality, full screen, full frame rate video, in less than
ideal bandwidth, storage, and processing power conditions without overlapping Iviewit's
proprietary rights, and since Iviewit management began discussions with representatives of Real 3D, Inc. some years ago we have watched our techniques drive across your product groups, including but not limited to microprocessors and chipsets for home entertainment PCs, and
embedded consumer electronics designs such as digital televisions, video recorders, and set-top
boxes.
Since Intel acquired the Real 3D business in 1999, pursuant to Iviewit/Real 3D contracts
and confidentiality agreements, therefore, you must similarly CEASE AND DESIST these
unauthorized uses on the aforementioned products, without limitation, learned in prior business
discussions.
and confidentiality agreements, therefore, you must similarly CEASE AND DESIST these
unauthorized uses on the aforementioned products, without limitation, learned in prior business
discussions.
Please take notice that this is advise of a future complaint seeking permanent injunction, and that the previous offer of license is withdrawn, and is substituted in its entirety by the attached
agreement, executable only for 30 days post hence, else Intel must CEASE AND DESIST the use of rendering full screen, full frame rate video and image overlays where an image can be zoomed upon and panned without pixelation from Intel products, and please advise if anything will prevent you from accepting our demand, in which case we will file suit shortly thereafter complaining of breach of prior confidential disclosures and our attached offer will be deemed withdrawn;
certainly, as a public company governed by the Securities and Exchange Act of 1934, you have
perfect record keeping of those 1999 discussions and the agreements signed thereunder.
Finally, I await timely execution of the attached and your request of wire transfer instructions,
where Iviewit is firmly committed to protecting its proprietary rights against any and all knowing and willful breaches of its confidential disclosures and disregard of recent advise and discussions.
Source of Post
http://iviewit.tv/press/press4.pdf
intel
Labels:
Bruce Sewell,
D. Bruce Sewell,
Evil Intel,
Intel,
P. Stephen Lamont
Silicon Graphics NEVER been Served.. What.. Trillion Dollar Fraud - Does anyone Care?
Look on Page 2 of this Link.. Well just Read this Whole
Court Document.. Trillion Dollar Liablity.. oh Well..
Fraud on the US Bankruptcy Courts
Let's Pretend we Just did not Know...
http://iviewit.tv/CompanyDocs/United%20States%20District%20Court%20Southern%20District%20NY/SGI%20Bankruptcy/Ramirez%20Declaration.pdf
intel
Court Document.. Trillion Dollar Liablity.. oh Well..
Fraud on the US Bankruptcy Courts
Let's Pretend we Just did not Know...
http://iviewit.tv/CompanyDocs/United%20States%20District%20Court%20Southern%20District%20NY/SGI%20Bankruptcy/Ramirez%20Declaration.pdf
intel
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Eliot I. Bernstein - Iviewit Technologies ALERTS Mary Schapiro to Massive Shareholder Fraud
Click Here for SEC Complaint
to Mary Schapiro and the SEC
Regarding Intel, Warner Bros,
Jeffrey Bewkes, Lockheed Martin,
Foley and Lardner, Proskauer Rose,
Kenneth Rubenstein, Christopher C. Wheeler,
the USPTO, Sony, SGI, Bankruptcy Courts,
Time Warner, Intel Corp, Time Inc.,
Wayne Smith of Warner, Douglas Chey,
John Calkins, P. Stephen Lamont,
the New York Attorney General,
NY Supreme Court, Florida Supreme Court,
the US Patent Office, IBM,
CEO Paul Otellini of Intel Corp., the Florida Attorney Bar,
the New York Attorney Bar, Michael Grebe,
the Bradley Foundation and a whole lot More.
Industry Whistle Blower Crystal L. Cox asks -
Do you have any Information on Bruce Sewell,
why he Left Intel Corp ?
Why he Denied Iviewit their Rights? or any other Whistleblowing on D. Bruce Sewell - aKa - Durward Bruce Sewell - Email me at Crystal@CrystalCox.com
Do you have any Information on Bruce Sewell,
why he Left Intel Corp ?
Why he Denied Iviewit their Rights? or any other Whistleblowing on D. Bruce Sewell - aKa - Durward Bruce Sewell - Email me at Crystal@CrystalCox.com